Scott's Sheet

When the Car Payment Starts Driving

Tow truck near a family car in a suburban driveway as bills pile up in the background
When the payment starts holding the keys.
Written by Scott K. James

Auto debt is squeezing working families, and a car payment that once meant freedom can start feeling like the thing holding the keys.

For a lot of working families, the car is not a luxury.

It is how you get to work, school, church, the grocery store, Grandma’s house, the doctor, practice, and the second job nobody posts about on Instagram.

So when the car payment gets too big, the whole household starts wobbling.

The New Yorker recently reported that America’s auto debt is nearing $1.7 trillion, with repossessions reaching levels not seen since the Great Recession. That is a big national number, but here is what it means in normal-person English:

America has put basic mobility on a payment plan, and the bill is now showing up in driveways.

This is not about turning the repo man into a cartoon villain. He may be the uncomfortable character in the story, but he is usually not the person who designed the machine. The bigger problem is the whole affordability system around the car: expensive vehicles, easy credit, high interest rates, high insurance, repairs that feel like medical procedures, and a culture that keeps telling people to finance normal life until normal life comes looking for the keys.

For many suburban and rural families, losing a car is not an inconvenience.

It is a crisis.

A broken transmission can become a family emergency. A missed payment can threaten a job. A job loss can trigger a late bill. A late bill can mean the car disappears from the driveway. Then the problem feeds itself, because it is hard to catch up when you cannot get to work.

That is the part the brunch-by-Uber crowd often misses. In much of America, transportation policy is your own steering wheel, your own tires, and whatever you can afford to keep running.

And right now, that is getting harder.

The New Yorker notes that the average price for a new car topped $50,000 last year. Since 2019, the average monthly payment for a new car has risen by about $300, and one in five new-car buyers is paying more than $1,000 a month.

A thousand dollars a month.

For a car.

That is not a payment. That is a small apartment with cup holders.

Meanwhile, families are already staring at rent or mortgage, groceries, insurance, utilities, childcare, gas, repairs, medical bills, and a grocery receipt that looks like it got mugged in the parking lot.

So yes, lenders deserve scrutiny. So do manufacturers. So do policymakers. So does an economy where wages and breathing room do not seem to live in the same county anymore.

But there is also an old-fashioned truth here that regular families may need to reclaim.

Debt is not magic money.

A bank approval is not a blessing.

And “you qualify” does not mean “you can afford it.”

That is not shame. That is survival wisdom.

There was a time when buying less car than the bank said you could afford was considered common sense. Today it almost sounds rebellious. But in a world of long loans, rising prices, and payments that follow people around like a bad dog, a little rebellion may be exactly what the household budget needs.

The point is not to scold people who are already squeezed. Most people are not trying to impress the neighbors with luxury trim packages and heated cupholders. They are trying to keep the wheels on, literally and otherwise.

But if freedom requires a monthly payment we can barely carry, maybe it is time to ask who is really driving.


Source: The New Yorker

About the author

Scott K. James

A 4th generation Northern Colorado native, Scott K. James is a veteran broadcaster, professional communicator, and principled leader. Widely recognized for his thoughtful, common-sense approach to addressing issues that affect families, businesses, and communities, Scott, his wife, Julie, and son, Jack, call Johnstown, Colorado, home. A former mayor of Johnstown, James is a staunch defender of the Constitution and the rule of law, the free market, and the power of the individual. Scott has delighted in a lifetime of public service and continues that service as a Weld County Commissioner representing District 2.

Share your thoughts...