Colorado Public Radio reports that the legal fight over Aurora’s privately operated immigrant detention center landed in federal court Friday. GEO Group is suing Colorado to block enforcement of a new state law requiring regular health and safety inspections at immigrant detention facilities. GEO argues the state is intruding into federal territory. Colorado and Adams County argue that communicable disease does not stop to check jurisdictional paperwork before spreading.
The immediate concern is tuberculosis. ICE says one confirmed case was treated, cleared and removed. But according to CPR, neither ICE nor GEO has provided documentation showing who may have been exposed, what follow-up occurred or whether appropriate protocols were completed. Adams County’s health director says GEO stopped communicating with investigators after a laboratory confirmed the case. GEO and ICE also did not answer CPR’s questions following the hearing.
So, after a federal hearing packed with government attorneys, corporate attorneys and arguments over statutory authority, the public remains stuck with the same basic question: What is actually happening inside a facility capable of holding more than a thousand people?
The Bullet Point Brief
- GEO Group says Colorado’s new inspection law unfairly targets the company and trespasses on federal authority. Apparently, tuberculosis is expected to respect the chain of command.
- Colorado and Adams County say public-health agencies have authority to investigate communicable diseases. Adams County requested medical records, access to relevant areas of the facility and information about detainees, employees and visitors who may have been exposed. Those are ordinary tools of disease control, not an armed raid on corporate sovereignty.
- Adams County Health Department Executive Director Kelly Weidenbach said GEO went “completely quiet” during the investigation. Nothing builds public confidence quite like a detention contractor responding to a tuberculosis inquiry with the institutional equivalent of hiding behind the couch.
- ICE says there are currently no confirmed active tuberculosis cases and that the known patient was treated and removed. But the agency has supplied what CPR described as the bare minimum of information, while GEO has not produced the paper trail needed to independently verify the response. Trust us, apparently, is now a public-health protocol.
- The judge issued no ruling, ICE sent no attorney to the hearing, GEO’s attorneys declined to answer questions afterward and local health officials still cannot say with confidence what conditions exist inside. Everybody has counsel. Nobody has clarity.
My Bottom Line
This should not be complicated. Aurora residents deserve to know whether a large detention facility in their community is competently managing a serious communicable disease. Employees go inside. Attorneys go inside. Contractors and delivery workers go inside. People eventually come out. Public health is not confined by razor wire, federal contracts or a lawyer’s interpretation of the supremacy clause.
GEO may have a legitimate legal argument about where state authority ends and federal authority begins. Let the court decide it. But a jurisdictional dispute is not a substitute for basic disclosure. If GEO followed proper protocols, produce the records and demonstrate it. If Adams County has authority, exercise it competently and explain the results. If ICE is responsible, then ICE should stop communicating like a malfunctioning fax machine and answer direct questions.
Colorado has perfected a particular kind of institutional scam. A private operator points at the federal government. The federal government points at its contractor. State and county officials point at their statutes. The attorneys point at one another. Then everyone bills for the meeting while the public is left outside wondering whether anybody is actually minding the store.
This is not an argument against immigration enforcement. A country must control its borders and may lawfully detain people while their cases are processed. It is an argument for competent government and accountable contracting. Secure facilities should also be safe facilities, and the public should not need a federal lawsuit, a courthouse confrontation and a decoder ring to learn whether a tuberculosis investigation was completed. Aurora deserves answers, not another performance from Colorado’s bureaucratic fog machine.
Source: Colorado Public Radio
Now It's Your Turn...