Scott's Sheet

Weld County’s Courthouse Bill Has No Magic Door

Editorial illustration of a Weld County courthouse, taxpayer bill, and Colorado landscape
No magic door, just hard courthouse math.
Written by Scott K. James

Weld County’s judicial center question sits where voter trust, state law, safe courts, and taxpayer responsibility all collide.

Nobody loves a courthouse bill.

That may be the least shocking sentence ever written by a county commissioner. Put it right up there with “road projects take longer than expected” and “the budget workshop did not improve anyone’s mood.”

But here we are.

BizWest reported this week on Weld County’s proposed judicial center and the legal question sitting right in the middle of it: our county charter limits large capital expenditures without voter approval, while state law requires counties to provide adequate court facilities. County Attorney Bruce Barker told elected officials that the state mandate may supersede the charter because Weld County is legally obligated to provide suitable court space.

That is where the frustration starts.

I believe in our charter. I believe voters matter. I believe taxpayers deserve a real say in how their money is spent. I also understand that Colorado law places the responsibility for court facilities on counties, even though the courts are part of the state judicial system.

In normal-person English: the state tells the county it must provide the courthouse, but the county taxpayer gets the bill.

That is an unfunded mandate with a marble lobby.

And no, government does not get to solve a hard problem by yelling at the instruction manual.

I have studied the documents. I have been in the meetings, the work sessions, and the long conversations where every “simple” answer lasted about six seconds before running headfirst into law, cost, timing, public safety, courthouse capacity, or basic county services.

This is complicated. That word gets overused in government, usually right before someone asks for more money. But in this case, it is true.

People want safe courts. They want responsible spending. They want honest answers. They do not want officials pretending there is a magic third door behind the curtain where we get the courthouse we need, spend less money, avoid delay, satisfy every legal requirement, and make nobody mad.

That door does not appear to exist.

The current facilities have been found unsuitable for present and future administration of justice. The county’s needs are growing. Renovation has been discussed, but the information presented to us shows it would cost a great deal and still not solve the long-term problem. Delay may feel cheaper today, but construction costs are not famous for getting more polite with age.

I am frustrated by the mandate. I am frustrated by the tension between our charter and state law. I am frustrated that counties are put in this position at all. But frustration is not a plan, and theatrics are not leadership.

So here is where I am.

I respect the voters. I will follow the law. I will continue to ask hard budget questions.

And I will report back as the legal and practical options become clearer.

Weld County residents deserve safe courts and honest stewardship. They deserve a process that does not insult their intelligence. And they deserve leaders who can say, plainly, when the choices are hard.

Because sometimes public service is not about finding the easy answer.

And it is always it is about telling the truth before the bill comes due – I will continue to do just that.


Source: BizWest

About the author

Scott K. James

A 4th generation Northern Colorado native, Scott K. James is a veteran broadcaster, professional communicator, and principled leader. Widely recognized for his thoughtful, common-sense approach to addressing issues that affect families, businesses, and communities, Scott, his wife, Julie, and son, Jack, call Johnstown, Colorado, home. A former mayor of Johnstown, James is a staunch defender of the Constitution and the rule of law, the free market, and the power of the individual. Scott has delighted in a lifetime of public service and continues that service as a Weld County Commissioner representing District 2.

Share your thoughts...