CBS News reports that President Trump’s big Guantanamo Bay immigration detention plan, announced days after he returned to the White House, has not come close to the 30,000-detainee vision he promised. According to internal government documents reviewed by CBS News and information provided to Congress, the operation is projected to cost the military $73 million while holding just six immigration detainees as of May 11.
The article says 832 immigration detainees have been transferred to Guantanamo over the past year on more than 100 flights, but the facility is now largely empty. CBS News also reports there are far more government employees assigned to the operation than detainees, with personnel outnumbering detainees by roughly 100 to 1.
The Bullet Point Brief
- Trump promised 30,000 detention beds at Guantanamo. CBS News says internal documents show the actual immigration detention capacity is roughly 400 beds. That is not a rounding error. That is a campaign rally and a forklift having a misunderstanding.
- As of May 11, the government was holding six immigration detainees there, all from Haiti, according to the documents CBS reviewed. Six. At that point, Guantanamo has less of a detention population and more of an awkward Airbnb situation.
- The operation is projected to cost $73 million for the military alone, up from a previously reported public estimate of $40 million. Washington has a gift for turning empty rooms into expensive rooms.
- CBS News says 522 Defense Department personnel and around 60 ICE and non-military staff are assigned to the mission. Government employees outnumber detainees about 100 to 1, which is either peak bureaucracy or the world’s most overstaffed check-in desk.
- Critics quoted by CBS, including Sen. Elizabeth Warren and the ACLU, call the operation wasteful, punitive, and political theater. DHS counters that people who come illegally and break U.S. laws could end up in Guantanamo, CECOT, or a third country. Subtle? No. Clear? Very.
My Bottom Line
CBS News was going to take a swing either way. If Guantanamo were packed, the headline would be cruelty, chaos, camps, and the usual dramatic fog machine. Since it is mostly empty, the headline is waste, theater, and incompetence. Funny how the narrative always lands in the same parking spot.
That said, conservatives do not have to pretend every Trump announcement was carved on tablets by Moses. If you promise 30,000 beds and end up with six detainees and a $73 million tab, people are allowed to ask questions. Border enforcement is not supposed to be performance art with a logistics contract.
The larger point still matters. Trump has been brutally effective at restoring border enforcement as a governing priority, and even this CBS piece acknowledges low levels of illegal crossings at the U.S.-Mexico border. That is not nothing. In fact, that is the whole ballgame for communities tired of Washington treating sovereignty like a rude suggestion.
But effectiveness is not a hall pass for expensive symbolism. Secure the border. Deport criminal illegal aliens. Enforce the law. Then keep the other promises too, especially the ones about staying out of dumb foreign wars. America First means America first, not press conferences first, consultants second, and taxpayers last.
Source: CBS News
Share your thoughts...