Political Sheet

Aurora ICE Protest Shooting: Words Are Not a Reason to Shoot

Protester on crutches outside the Aurora ICE detention facility during a demonstration
Words are not a reason to shoot.
Written by Scott K. James

A shooting outside Aurora’s ICE detention facility has produced serious charges and an embarrassingly basic reminder: political anger is not self-defense.

Colorado Public Radio reports that 22-year-old Emma Landis returned to protest outside the Aurora ICE detention facility just days after she was shot in the foot there. Aurora police arrested 42-year-old Brandon Booth, an employee of facility operator GEO Group, shortly after the shooting. He was later booked on suspicion of attempted second-degree murder, first-degree assault, attempted first-degree assault, felony menacing and unlawfully carrying a concealed weapon.

According to police, Booth and coworkers had been unable to enter the facility for their shifts because of the protest. Two women reportedly photographed employees’ cars and got into a verbal altercation with them before walking away. Police allege Booth then pulled his personal firearm, fired one shot toward the women, struck Landis and drove off. His bond was set at $500,000. GEO placed him on unpaid administrative leave and said it would cooperate with law enforcement.

Landis came back on crutches and put the whole issue into one sentence: “Because somebody was hurt by the words that I was saying to him, that doesn’t give you the right to shoot somebody.” That is the spine of this story. Hurt feelings are not a concealed-carry permit. Political anger is not self-defense. And an offensive sentence, stupid sign or ugly argument does not turn a sidewalk into a free-fire zone.

The Bullet Point Brief

  • A protester was shot outside the Aurora ICE facility. Landis says she was on the sidewalk protesting when she was hit in the right foot. Police arrested Booth near the facility shortly afterward. This is no longer a shouting match. It is a felony case.
  • Authorities have alleged a sequence of events, not a proven motive. Police say there was a verbal confrontation, the women walked away and Booth fired one shot in their direction. The criminal charges are serious, but the case still belongs in court, not in the imagination of whichever political tribe reaches social media first.
  • Landis returned to protest while recovering. CPR’s photos show her using crutches and speaking with her injured foot wrapped. She said she faces six to eight weeks of bed rest and cannot work or enjoy her normal activities. Political violence has a way of turning slogans into medical bills.
  • Protests continued after the shooting. Demonstrators held another action in Centennial, where four people were arrested during a “die-in” for blocking an entrance or standing in the roadway. Protest rights matter. So do traffic laws. A free society requires enough brainpower to understand both at the same time.
  • The central principle is embarrassingly basic. You may hate the protest. You may hate ICE. You may hate the sign, the chant, the speaker or the entire miserable scene. None of that gives anyone permission to pull a gun. Congratulations, you have discovered kindergarten with felony consequences.

My Bottom Line

People have the right to protest a federal detention facility. Other people have the right to disagree with them, criticize them and think their message is foolish, dishonest or obnoxious. What nobody has is a constitutional right to settle political arguments with gunfire.

Landis does not have to be canonized as a saint for her rights to matter. Her politics are beside the point. Free speech is not reserved for calm people holding tasteful signs between approved hours. It protects aggravating speech too. In fact, that is when it matters most. A society that only tolerates words nobody objects to has not protected speech. It has protected background noise.

Colorado’s public square is starting to look like a daycare run by rage merchants. Activists escalate. Tough guys posture. Institutions issue statements. Consultants schedule listening sessions. Everyone claims their panic is righteous, and then somebody gets hurt while the adults search for a task force and a vocabulary guide.

The rule is simple. Use your words. Do not shoot people. Do not turn Aurora into Mad Max with better grant funding. When a political argument outside a government-linked facility becomes a police report, the problem is bigger than ICE, GEO or one protest. The problem is a civic culture full of overgrown toddlers with slogans, grudges and no damn brakes.


Source: Colorado Public Radio