Cigar Stories

A Noob’s Guide to Smoking Cigars Like You Were Born Doing It

Written by Scott K. James

New to cigars? Welcome to the brotherhood. Learn how to cut, light, smoke, and savor premium sticks without looking like a total jackass.

My First Cigar: How the Madness Began

You never forget your first time.

(And no, I’m not talking about that first time, you degenerates.)

I was paired up with an old guy on the golf course — you know the type: khaki pants, permanent tan, swing smoother than a Sinatra track. Halfway through the round, he reaches into his bag and offers me a cigar like it’s the most natural thing in the world. And when I say offered, I mean offered with rules — because he had to show me everything: how to cut it, how to light it, how to smoke it without looking like I was trying to suck a watermelon through a garden hose.

It wasn’t just about the smoke. It was the whole ritual: the unwrapping, the slow cut, the careful toast, the patient puffing. That one cigar led me down a thirty-plus-year love affair with premium, hand-rolled tobacco that still hasn’t let up. And I wouldn’t trade it for anything — not even a lower golf handicap.

Because cigars aren’t just about the flavor.

They’re about time, ritual, relaxation, and respect.

Why I Love Cigars (And Why You Will Too)

Sure, the taste matters — deep earth, roasted coffee, chocolate, pepper, spice, sweetness… real cigars taste like the stories your grandfather never got around to telling.

But it’s the ritual that locks you in:

  • Selecting the right cigar like it’s a weapon of choice.
  • Cutting it just right — a small ceremony of precision.
  • Toasting it, letting the first gentle embers bring it alive.
  • Savoring the first draw — patient, measured, reverent.

When you’re smoking a cigar, you’re not rushing.
You’re not doomscrolling.
You’re present.

Cigars demand your time — and in a world addicted to cheap dopamine hits, that’s a revolution.

Quick Tips for Noobs (Welcome to the Family)

Here’s the deal: nobody’s judging you. We were all noobs once.

But if you want to jump in without looking like you escaped from a clown car, here’s your game plan:

1. The Cut

First rule: Don’t chop your cigar like you’re opening a bag of beef jerky.

  • Straight Cut: Most common. Use a guillotine-style cutter. Chop just the cap — that little rounded end — not half the damn cigar.
  • V-Cut: A “V” notch slice. Makes for a cooler, concentrated draw. Great for thicker sticks.
  • Punch Cut: Pokes a perfect circle into the cap. Clean. Less messy. Feels like you’re operating high-end spy gear.

🗣️ Pro Tip: Always cut above the shoulder of the cigar. If you cut too low, it’ll unravel faster than your New Year’s resolutions.

2. The Light

This isn’t a campfire. You’re not trying to torch it into oblivion.

  • Use a butane torch lighter or wooden matches (no Bic lighters unless you want your cigar tasting like an armpit).
  • Toast the foot (the open end) first — keep the flame just close enough to heat it without touching it. Spin it slowly.
  • Once toasted, draw gently while you bring the flame closer, rotating as you puff.

🗣️ Pro Tip: Sir Winston Churchill once said, “A cigar is to be lit with reverence — and only once.” Respect the man. Respect the cigar.

3. The Smoke

Noobs tend to either:

  • Puff like a steam train on meth, or
  • Suck so hard you wonder if they’re trying to recreate a tornado.

Here’s how to do it:

  • Puff, don’t inhale. You’re tasting, not mainlining it.
  • Sip the smoke. Let it dance in your mouth. Blow it out gently.
  • Go slow. One puff every 30 seconds to a minute is ideal. If you’re trying to keep up with your cigarette buddy, you’re doing it wrong.

4. The Finish

When you’re done, let the cigar die a dignified death.
No stamping it out like a cigarette.
No mashing it into the ashtray like you’re putting out a dumpster fire.

  • Just set it down.
  • Let it quietly go out on its own.

🗣️ Pro Tip: Real smokers respect the cigar — from birth to death.

5. Other Critical Noob Survival Tips

  • Don’t lick your cigar. You’re not a dog in heat. There’s no reason to slobber all over it.
  • Fix an uneven burn: Rotate the slower burning side upward. Heat rises, and the uneven burn usually self-corrects.
  • If it goes out: Just relight it the same way you lit it the first time — gently toasting the foot, puffing it back to life. No shame, just class.

The Top 5 Beginner Cigars (Because Starting Right Matters)

Here’s your noob starter kit. Five cigars that won’t kick your teeth in, but will open the door to the good life:

1. Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Toro

  • Price: ~$9–11
  • Flavor Profile: Toasted almonds, cedar, smooth cream.
  • Strength: Mild to Medium
  • Size: 6″ x 54
  • Why You Need It:
    Elegant, approachable, smooth as hell — like sipping bourbon with Sinatra.
  • Buy It: JR Cigars

2. Arturo Fuente 858 Natural

  • Price: ~$7–9
  • Flavor Profile: Nutty, earthy, slight sweetness.
  • Strength: Mild to Medium
  • Size: 6″ x 47
  • Why You Need It:
    A classic. If you don’t love this, maybe cigars aren’t your thing.
  • Buy It: Neptune Cigar

3. Oliva Connecticut Reserve Robusto

  • Price: ~$6–8
  • Flavor Profile: Creamy coffee, light wood, subtle spice.
  • Strength: Mild
  • Size: 5″ x 50
  • Why You Need It:
    Super smooth, won’t wreck your palate, perfect for morning or chill sessions.
  • Buy It: Cigars International

4. Perdomo Champagne 10th Anniversary Robusto

  • Price: ~$8–10
  • Flavor Profile: Honey, cream, toasty cedar.
  • Strength: Mild to Medium
  • Size: 5″ x 54
  • Why You Need It:
    Silky, luxurious, and exactly what you need to feel like you’re doing something right with your life.
  • Buy It: Thompson Cigar

5. Avo Classic No. 2

  • Price: ~$10–12
  • Flavor Profile: Soft pepper, sweet cream, breadiness.
  • Strength: Mild to Medium
  • Size: 6″ x 50
  • Why You Need It:
    Avo is like jazz in cigar form — smooth, soulful, and something you need to experience firsthand.
  • Buy It: Davidoff of Geneva

Final Draw

If you’re new to cigars, welcome.

You just joined a club older, cooler, and way more forgiving than any golf membership or whiskey tasting room.

Light up. Relax. Learn. Screw up a few times. Laugh about it. Light another one.

You’re not just smoking a cigar — you’re carving out a little piece of the world that belongs only to you.

And trust me, brother — there’s nothing better than that.

🔥💨🥃

About the author

Scott K. James

A 4th generation Northern Colorado native, Scott K. James is a veteran broadcaster, professional communicator, and principled leader. Widely recognized for his thoughtful, common-sense approach to addressing issues that affect families, businesses, and communities, Scott, his wife, Julie, and son, Jack, call Johnstown, Colorado, home. A former mayor of Johnstown, James is a staunch defender of the Constitution and the rule of law, the free market, and the power of the individual. Scott has delighted in a lifetime of public service and continues that service as a Weld County Commissioner representing District 2.

Share your thoughts...